The Place of Maimonides in Zechariah Frankel's Darkhei HaMishnah - 10.1628/jsq-2021-0004 - Mohr Siebeck
Jewish Studies

Daniel Mackler

The Place of Maimonides in Zechariah Frankel's Darkhei HaMishnah

Section: Articles
Jewish Studies Quarterly (JSQ)

Volume 28 () / Issue 1, pp. 54-80 (27)
Published 15.02.2021

27,00 € including VAT
article PDF
Zechariah Frankel's Darkhei HaMishnah (1859) has been treated in the literature as either a) an early critical-textual work on the Mishnah or b) a novel theological statement for the human origin of the Mishnah. By examining the relation of Darkhei HaMishnah to Maimonides − another pioneering mishnaic scholar − I depart from both of these frames. Beyond the bounds of critical-textual scholarship, Darkhei HaMishnah casts the rejection of Greek philosophy as the founding intellectual gesture of rabbinic Judaism; this ultimately leads Frankel to deny that Maimonides was genuinely invested in the reasons for the commandments, or even in philosophy more broadly. On the question of the Mishnah's origin, Maimonides himself radically circumscribed the revelation of Oral Torah, and, like Frankel, he was roundly criticized for it. More than the novelty of Frankel's claim, the particular religious anxieties of 19th-century Germany Jewry were the necessary conditions for the controversy around Darkhei HaMishnah.

Daniel Mackler No current data available.