Back to issue
Cover of: Why do Judges Grant Rehearing Requests? Evidence from the Supreme Court of Israel
Yehonatan Givati, Israel Rosenberg

Why do Judges Grant Rehearing Requests? Evidence from the Supreme Court of Israel

Section: Conference Article 1
Volume 179 (2023) / Issue 1, pp. 6-22 (17)
Published 31.01.2023
DOI 10.1628/jite-2023-0011
  • article PDF
  • available
  • 10.1628/jite-2023-0011
Summary
Why do judges grant rehearing requests? We focus on rehearing requests in the Supreme Court of Israel, where the decision to hold a rehearing is made by a single judge and is documented. Using original data on all rehearing decisions since 2006, we find that judges who grant requests for a rehearing, are much more likely than other judges on the same rehearing panel, to reverse the original ruling in the rehearing. This difference is especially large for politically salient cases. This finding is consistent with the idea that judges grant rehearing requests when they disagree with the original ruling, from a policy perspective.