Subsumption is a term which enjoys a long tradition in jurisprudence and which can be traced back to an established use in logic. Unlike in logic however the subsumption process is a contentious issue in legal methodology, since there is not even an agreement on the meaning of the term. This varies depending on the location, standpoint, and linguistic usage of the user. In this volume, various philosophical and legal scholars, all of whom are well-versed in methodology, state their positions ranging from the Aristotelian approach and Kant's and Hegel's concepts to current model methodologies of hermeneutic, pragmatic, phenomenological and rhetorical legal theory.
Subsumption is a term which enjoys a long tradition in jurisprudence and which can be traced back to an established use in logic. Unlike in logic however the subsumption process is a contentious issue in legal methodology, since there is not even an agreement on the meaning of the term. This varies depending on the location, standpoint, and linguistic usage of the user. In this volume, various philosophical and legal scholars, all of whom are well-versed in methodology, state their positions ranging from the Aristotelian approach and Kant's and Hegel's concepts to current model methodologies of hermeneutic, pragmatic, phenomenological and rhetorical legal theory.
Table of contents:
Gottfried Gabriel: Subsumierende und reflektierende Urteilskraft. Zur Vermittlung zwischen Allgemeinem und Besonderem im Justizsyllogismus -
Temilo van Zantwijk: Subsumtion in aristotelischer Tradition. Juristischer Syllogismus oder rhetorisches Argument? -
Pirmin Stekeler-Weithofer: Subsumtion bei Hegel -
Oliver W. Lembcke: Urteilskraft in der Praxis des Bundesverfassungsgerichts. Eine Erinnerung an Hannah Arendt -
Matthias Jung: Applikation zwischen Subsumtion und Abduktion. Hat die juristische Hermeneutik Modellfunktion für die allgemeine? -
Ulrich Schroth: Juristische und philosophische Hermeneutik -
Stephan Meder: Auslegung als Kunst bei Savigny
-
MartinMorlok: Die vier Auslegungsmethoden - was sonst? -
Jochen Bung: Der juristische Syllogismus in der Methodenlehre von Larenz -
Jan Schapp: Der Fall in der juristischen Methodenlehre -
Joachim Lege: Subsumtion pragmatisch: Deduktion, Induktion und Abduktion -
Ralph Christensen: Konkretisierung des Gesetzes - linguistisch betrachtet -
Ulfrid Neumann: Subsumtion als regelorientierte Fallentscheidung -
Hans-Joachim Strauch: Mustererkennung und Subsumtion im Erkenntnisverfahren -
Katharina Gräfin von Schlieffen: Subsumtion als Darstellung der Herstellung juristischer Urteile -
RolfGröschner: Logik und Dialogik der Subsumtion
