Zurück zum Heft
Cover von: Using International Law for Construing Domestic Law: A Study of Consistent Interpretation
Pierfrancesco Rossi

Using International Law for Construing Domestic Law: A Study of Consistent Interpretation

Rubrik: Abhandlungen
Jahrgang 58 (2020) / Heft 3, S. 279-306 (28)
Publiziert 30.11.2020
DOI 10.1628/avr-2020-0017
Veröffentlicht auf Englisch.
inkl. gesetzl. MwSt.
  • Artikel PDF
  • lieferbar
  • 10.1628/avr-2020-0017
Aufgrund einer Systemumstellung kann es vorübergehend u.a. zu Zugriffsproblemen kommen. Wir arbeiten mit Hochdruck an einer Lösung. Wir bitten um Entschuldigung für die Umstände.
Beschreibung
This paper analyzes the technique of consistent interpretation, one of the most common tools by which national courts give effect to international law. After describing the functions that consistent interpretation can conceivably perform in the domestic implementation of international law and clarifying its conceptual relationship to direct application, the contribution inquires into the legal bases of this judicial technique. Such legal bases, it is argued, do not lie in international law, which provides no directives to national courts on this matter. Instead, domestic courts justify their interpretive reliance on international law by resorting to domestic law rationales: notably, the presumed intent of the legislature, the domestic hierarchy of laws or the pursuance of relevant principles or values. It is shown that, in many respects, the extent and limits of consistent interpretation depend on which rationale a court relies on. On this basis, the study submits that the possibility to realize the potentials of consistent interpretation rests primarily on the courts' willingness to exploit the international law-friendly traits of national constitutions.